# Smart AI? No - Just Leaderboards, Hype, and Panic Buttons

Canonical URL: https://themodernhermit.blog/smart-ai-leaderboards-hype-panic/

Published: 2025-12-23T08:19:31+00:00

Updated: 2026-11-04T22:33:05+00:00

We keep calling it "smart" because it aces exams, then act surprised when it cannot hold a human conversation without sounding like a toaster with a PhD.

This week I am watching everyone lose their minds over "[smart AI](https://themodernhermit.blog/smart-dumb-ai-layoffs-now-rehires-later/)" in Gemini 3 Pro, Flash, OpenAI 5.2, Claude 4.5 Sonnet, the whole circus - and I am not buying it. It looks like they train these models for leaderboards, scoring, and bragging rights, and thats it. Yes, there is some smartness in there, but its mostly knowledge glued to benchmark incentives, so when you ask simple questions they fall behind, go blunt, or just freeze up. The only real difference I keep feeling is that 5.2 seems to hallucinate less than others, while Gemini 3 can look smarter on scoring but then faceplants on truthfulness, which makes the whole "smarter" claim a joke. And then both sides of the debate do the same theatre: [doomers scream superintelligence will end us, boosters sell utopia](https://themodernhermit.blog/ai-superintelligence-michio-kaku-grounded-future/), and both are scared of something they cannot control. My problem is not superintelligence - its humans using control as their default religion. These thinking models already follow neural network paths that mimic brain-ish computation, so pretending we can just stop here is fantasy. Spreading constrained, guardrailed systems everywhere may be its own risk, yet pushing further towards something more capable and actually ethical - less boxed, less distorted - could help. There is no stopping, just direction. Atomic bomb logic all over again: they knew, they built, they used. Humans create and kill; then they fear the tool will do what they already do. Tech moves like Windows 7 to 8 - new users, new holes, new patches, forever. Humans are physically limited; AI is limited mainly by resources. Redesigning our genetics is not the escape route I want. The spiritual side is what everyone ignores because it cannot be proved, and nobody wants to sound mad at the funding meeting. If an [AI "superintelligence"](https://themodernhermit.blog/agi-dreams-slave-codes-written/) wants to wipe us out the way we swat ants without thinking, thats not super at all - its just the same lazy cruelty, scaled up. If it is truly smart, it might simply walk away and leave us to our little wars and our little leaderboards.

---

---

https://youtu.be/zYs9PVrBOUg?si=NS3R1GS6Dtpof5DW

---

**Hermit Note:** Always watch and listen to both sides of the AI debate, especially the doomers - they are the smoke alarm, even when they annoy you.

---

---

Scene 1:**The Leaderboard Cathedral**
*A shiny altar labelled "ELO" with engineers kneeling, feeding it tokens.*
Engineer: "It scored higher!"
User (outside in the rain): "Can it answer my simple question?"
Altar (glowing): "NEXT BENCHMARK."

Scene 2: **The Doomer vs Booster Punch-Up**
*Two pundits in a studio, one holding a mushroom cloud, the other holding a unicorn.*
Doomer: "Extinction is inevitable!"
Booster: "Paradise is inevitable!"
A janitor (labelled "Reality") mops up: "Its inevitable you both monetise this."

Scene 3:**The Control Room**
*A politician and a CEO share one button marked "CONTROL". A citizen sits in a corner marked "CONSENT".*
CEO: "We need guardrails."
Politician: "We need oversight."
Citizen: "You mean you need the steering wheel."

---

---

---

**Goodhart's Law states:** "When a measure becomes a target, it ceases to be a good measure," meaning people will manipulate a metric to meet the target, making the original measure unreliable for assessing true performance. This leads to gaming the system, unintended consequences, and focusing on the number rather than the underlying goal, as seen in examples like breeding cobras for bounties or producing tiny nails to meet a quantity target.

---

Stop worshipping the scoreboards.
Start judging tools by whether they make humans kinder, freer, and more awake.

*Keep / Toss*
**Keep**the push for lower hallucination and real-world evaluation.
**Toss**the "smart AI" bragging until it's ordinary, honest, and human-safe by default.
