# Dumb tools, rich hype: how AI reviewers still keep us fooled

Canonical URL: https://themodernhermit.blog/dumb-tools-rich-hype-ai-reviewers/

Published: 2025-12-12T09:15:36+00:00

Updated: 2026-11-04T22:33:29+00:00

We are paying premium prices for tools that think like monkeys with forks while reviewers write sonnets about their genius.

> What annoys me lately is how banana pro is somehow treated like a breakthrough when it thinks like a monkey that just learned how to eat with a fork. It can follow tools, sure, but the moment it has to think, it goes whole zoo exhibit. Then there is Gemini, suddenly mainstream and paraded as the clever one, yet, outside the so-called deep-thinking mode, it feels like the dumbest thing you could use for daily tasks. I genuinely cannot explain that rise except by assuming most high-profile reviewers are paid, or at least happily sponsored, to praise these stupid releases. At the same time, only a few voices still call them what they are: dumb models trained on a pile of data, wrapped in marketing about smartness. Yes, they spit out images and essays that sound clever, but read three in a row, and you see the same lines shuffled like a cheap card trick. The only thing that even looks interesting is the long, extensive thinking flavour of GPT 5 point something, and even that still feels dumb as hell. The rest are blank. Tools, nothing more. Yet they are sold back to us as near divine minds, because money has to be pulled from our pockets. Agentic AI is hyped as the next revolution, but right now, it is even more useless and niche, a toy for demos and reviewers selling us stories, not a thing anyone sane would pay for. This roast is for every high-praising AI reviewer still pretending this circus is wisdom.

**Scene 1: Monkey with a fork**
Panel description: A smug monkey in a lab coat holds a fork and a glowing "banana pro" tablet while tech journalists crowd around taking notes.
Dialogue:
Reviewer: "It used a tool AND wrote a paragraph. This is basically a new civilisation."
User: "It still failed 2+2."
Monkey: "But I clicked the tool button!"
**Scene 2: Gemini altar call**
Panel description: A sleek shrine labelled "Gemini Hype" with three subscription tiers as candles: Free, Pro, Ultra. A normal user opens their wallet while a reviewer in a blazer preaches.
Dialogue:
Reviewer: "For only 20 a month, it can think deeply for you!"
User: "So why do I still have to fact check everything?"
Tiny caption on altar: "Hallucinations included."
**Scene 3: Agentic circus**
Panel description: A chaotic circus ring called "Agentic AI." Tiny clown agents juggle tasks, drop them, and run in circles. A tired user holds a clipboard.
Dialogue:
Ringmaster reviewer: "Behold, the future of work!"
User: "I am still doing all the work."
One small clown agent: "Task failed, try upgrading to Ultra."

---

---

Treat these things as spanners, not sages, and most of the nonsense melts away. The real danger starts when you let the marketing team define what intelligence is.

**Verdict**: Toss

**Keep**the idea that models are just tools and should be priced and judged as such.
**Toss**the worship of banana pro, Gemini, and every agentic circus act as if they are new gods, plus the reviewers who keep bowing for a free subscription.

---

---

**Satire and commentary.** Opinion pieces for discussion. Sources at the end. Not legal, medical, financial, or professional advice.

---
